Understanding a Currency PegUnderstanding a Currency Peg: Definition, Mechanisms, and Implications
Fixed exchange rates, a cornerstone of international finance, play a pivotal role in shaping global commerce and investment landscapes. This article delves into their intricacies, exploring the historical evolution, practical understanding, and the balance of benefits and challenges they present.
Historical Context of Fixed Exchange Rates
The concept of fixed exchange rate systems has evolved over centuries, but its modern form gained prominence with the Bretton Woods Agreement in 1944. This system was designed to rebuild the global economy after World War II by creating a stable international monetary framework. Under the Bretton Woods system, countries pegged their currencies to the US dollar, which in turn was backed by gold at a fixed rate of $35 per ounce. This arrangement aimed to maintain relative exchange rate stability, promote international trade, and prevent competitive currency devaluations.
To support this fixed exchange rate regime, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) was established, providing financial assistance to countries facing balance of payments problems. While Bretton Woods initially succeeded in fostering economic stability, it began to falter in the 1960s due to rising inflation and balance of payment deficits in the US. In 1971, the US suspended gold convertibility, leading to the system’s collapse and a shift toward floating exchange rates.
Despite its end, the legacy of fixed exchange rates continues, as many countries still choose to peg their currencies to major currencies like the US dollar or the euro, seeking the economic predictability such systems offer.
Understanding Fixed Exchange Rates
A fixed exchange rate is a system where a country's currency value is tied to another major currency or a basket of currencies. Specifically, when a currency peg is established, the government commits to maintaining the currency within a specified narrow range around the targeted rate, often within a band of ±1% to ±2%.
Role of Central Banks and Foreign Reserves
Central banks play a pivotal role in maintaining a pegged currency. To defend the peg, a central bank must actively intervene in the foreign exchange (forex) market. When the currency’s value drifts from the fixed rate, the central bank buys or sells its currency to adjust supply and demand, keeping the value within the target range.
These operations require substantial foreign reserves—typically in the currency to which the domestic currency is anchored. These reserves act as a buffer to absorb shocks and counteract any pressures that could destabilise the peg.
Impact on Monetary Policy and Interest Rates
Maintaining currency pegging has a significant impact on a country's monetary policy. The central bank's primary focus becomes defending the peg, often at the expense of other economic goals, such as controlling inflation or stimulating growth.
Since the central bank must prioritise the peg, it has limited ability to set interest rates independently. Instead, interest rates often need to align closely with those of the anchor currency’s country to prevent capital flight and maintain the anchor’s credibility. This lack of flexibility can lead to challenges, particularly when the economic conditions in the pegging country differ from those in the anchor currency’s economy.
Implications of a Currency Peg
For the pegging country, a currency peg may offer economic stability and predictability, which are vital for fostering a favourable environment for trade and investment. Businesses can plan with greater certainty, knowing conversion rates will remain stable.
However, all this comes with significant challenges. Countries with fixed exchange rates often lose autonomy over their monetary policy, as maintaining the anchor becomes the primary focus. This can limit the country's ability to respond to domestic economic issues. Additionally, a currency peg can impact the trade balance; if the anchored currency is overvalued, it may harm exports, while an undervalued peg could increase inflation.
On a global scale, pegged exchange rates influence international trade and investment flows by reducing exchange rate volatility, making global transactions smoother. However, these systems also carry risks. If a pegged currency becomes misaligned with its true economic value, it can attract speculative attacks, where investors bet against the currency, leading to potential financial crises. Such scenarios can destabilise not only the pegging country but also ripple through global markets and negatively impact the world economy.
List of Fixed Exchange Rate Currencies
As of 2024, several currencies operate under a fixed exchange rate system. Notable fixed exchange rate examples include:
- Hong Kong dollar (HKD) - One of the most well-known currencies anchored to the USD, the HKD is maintained at approximately 7.8 to the US dollar, providing relative stability to Hong Kong’s financial markets since 1983.
- United Arab Emirates dirham (AED) - Pegged to the US dollar since 1997, the AED is maintained at around 3.67 to 1 USD, supporting the UAE's oil-driven economy.
- West African CFA franc (XOF) and Central African CFA franc (XAF) - Both pegged to the euro at a fixed rate of 655.957 CFA francs to 1 euro, these currencies provide economic stability across 14 African countries.
- Bahamian dollar (BSD) - Anchored to the US dollar at a 1:1 ratio, the BSD facilitates trade and tourism in the Bahamas, closely linked to the US economy.
- Danish krone (DKK) - Pegged to the euro within a narrow band, typically around 7.46 DKK to 1 euro, the krone's peg supports Denmark’s economic ties with the Eurozone.
- Saudi riyal (SAR) - Pegged to the US dollar since 1986, the SAR is maintained at approximately 3.75 to 1 USD, stabilising Saudi Arabia's oil-reliant economy.
Fixed Exchange Rate Pros and Cons
While many economies choose a floating system nowadays, there are pros and cons of a fixed exchange rate.
Advantages of a Fixed Exchange Rate
- Stability in Global Trade: Pegged currencies reduce the uncertainty and risk associated with floating currencies, making it easier for businesses to plan and engage in international commerce.
- Reduced Risk in International Investments: Investors are more likely to invest in countries with currencies that have predetermined rates because it lowers the risk of losing money through price fluctuations.
- Control of Inflation Rates: Countries can maintain low inflation levels by pegging their currency to a stable, low-inflation economy.
- Prevent Competitive Devaluations: Such a regime prevents countries from engaging in competitive devaluations, which may lead to a 'race to the bottom' and global economic instability.
- Increased Policy Discipline: Anchored rates can impose discipline on a country's fiscal and monetary policies, as maintaining the peg requires consistent, responsible economic management.
- Simplified Transactions: A fixed currency simplifies the process of global transactions by providing predictability in exchange costs, reducing the need for complex hedging strategies.
Disadvantages of a Fixed Exchange Rate
- Overvaluation or Undervaluation: Maintaining a set rate might lead to misalignment, where a currency may become overvalued or undervalued relative to its economic fundamentals.
- High Costs of Maintenance: To maintain the peg, countries often need to hold large reserves of foreign currency, which may be costly and economically inefficient.
- Lack of Monetary Policy Flexibility: Countries lose the ability to set their own interest rates and conduct independent monetary policy, as they must focus on maintaining the peg.
- Vulnerability to External Shocks: Tied conversion rates can make a country more susceptible to economic problems in the nation to which its currency is pegged.
- Reduced Responsiveness to Domestic Conditions: An anchored currency regime limits a country’s ability to respond to domestic economic changes, such as inflation, unemployment, or economic downturns.
- Risk of Speculative Attacks: If investors believe a currency is overvalued or undervalued, they may engage in speculative attacks, leading to severe financial crises.
Fixed Exchange Rates in Modern Trading
In modern trading, understanding the dynamics of fixed currencies offers traders specific advantages and insights:
- Forex Pairs: Traders can anticipate less volatility in forex involving a fixed value, allowing for more solid long-term trading strategies.
- Indicator of Economic Policies: The status and changes in a fixed rate potentially signal shifts in a country's monetary and fiscal policies, providing traders with crucial information for decision-making.
- Trade and Investment Decisions: Understanding which countries have pegged rates can guide traders in making informed decisions about trade and investment opportunities.
The Bottom Line
Grasping the nuances of fixed exchange rates is crucial for anyone involved in international finance. Whether weighing their pros and cons for trading or observing their impact on financial markets, this knowledge is invaluable. For those looking to apply this understanding practically, opening an FXOpen account can be a strategic step, offering a platform to navigate and capitalise on the opportunities in the global financial markets.
FAQ
What Does Pegging Currency Mean?
The pegging currency meaning refers to fixing its value to another major currency or a basket of currencies. This is done to provide stability in international trade and reduce forex rate volatility.
What Currencies Are Pegged to the Dollar?
There are several currencies pegged to USD, including the Hong Kong dollar (HKD), United Arab Emirates dirham (AED), Saudi riyal (SAR), and Bahamian dollar (BSD), among others. These currencies maintain a fixed exchange rate with the dollar to ensure economic stability.
Why Would Another Country Want to Peg Its Currency to the US Dollar?
Countries peg their currency to the US dollar to gain economic stability, attract foreign investment, and stabilise trade with the US. The dollar’s global dominance makes it a reliable anchor for maintaining economic predictability.
What Is a Disadvantage for a Country Utilising a Currency Peg?
A significant disadvantage of a currency peg is the loss of monetary policy autonomy. The anchoring country must prioritise maintaining the peg, limiting its ability to respond to domestic economic conditions like inflation or recession.
Trade on TradingView with FXOpen. Consider opening an account and access over 700 markets with tight spreads from 0.0 pips and low commissions from $1.50 per lot.
This article represents the opinion of the Companies operating under the FXOpen brand only. It is not to be construed as an offer, solicitation, or recommendation with respect to products and services provided by the Companies operating under the FXOpen brand, nor is it to be considered financial advice.
XAF
Sector Rotation in Anticipation of Rate CutsMarkets have rebounded sharply after last week's fear-driven decline. Despite this, rate cuts are still anticipated in the upcoming FOMC meetings. Changes in monetary policy often benefit some sectors over others, providing investors a chance to adjust their portfolio allocations accordingly.
This paper delves into a comparative analysis of sectors around monetary policy pivots to highlight how a spread between S&P Financials Select Sector and S&P Utilities Select Sector stands to benefit in the coming months. It also describes a hypothetical trade setup using CME E-Mini S&P Select Sector futures which can be used to express the view in a margin-efficient manner.
RATE CUTS WILL HURT FINANCIAL FIRMS
Financial firms benefit significantly from higher rates, as these drive net interest margin (NIM) expansion, boosting their bottom line. However, when rates start to decrease, this positive impact reverses.
The Financials Select Sector ETF (XLF) is comprised of 25% banks, 31% financial services firms, and 16.6% insurance firms. All these firms have benefited from higher rates, albeit the strongest impact may be limited to banks and insurance firms whose overall bottom line is significantly impacted by expanding NIM.
In the last three monetary policy pivots, XLF has declined by an average of 5.6% over the following six months. Conversely, at the start of rate hikes, the ETF has typically risen by an average of 3.7% in the subsequent six months. While the most recent pivot in 2019 saw an increase in XLF, the overall average trend suggests a decline.
The trend is visible even when examining the relative performance of XLF and SPX. Following rate cuts, the spread declined by an average of 2.8% while during rate increases, it declined by just 1.1%.
There is another headwind facing the XLF ETF, particularly banks – rising credit delinquencies. Credit card delinquencies are especially concerning as they stood at the highest level in 13 years as of Q1 2024. Overall delinquencies are also rising and near the highest level since 2021.
Updated data from the New York Fed has shown that conditions remained stressed in Q2 with total delinquencies at 3.2%. Particularly concerning were severe (>90 days delinquent) credit card delinquencies at a staggering 10.93%. Consumers are increasingly relying on unsustainable credit card debt to cover expenses. As delinquencies remain elevated, issuing banks must increase loan loss provisions which impacts earnings directly.
Source: New York Fed
As credit card usage becomes unsustainable, another class of companies in XLF – payment processors - will also be hurt. The largest payment processors (Visa, Mastercard, and Amex) represent nearly 15% of the XLF index.
RATE CUTS WILL BENEFIT UTILITY FIRMS
Unlike financial firms, utility companies have struggled in a high-rate environment. As their huge capital expenditure is often fueled by debt, higher rates result in narrower profits.
As rates decline, debt payments decrease, leading to expanded profit margins for utility firms. Historically, the ETF has shown a significant average increase after rate hikes and a smaller increase after rate cuts. This behavior might be due to investors anticipating a weakening economy following rate cuts, which would favor utility firms. However, the index tends to correct later once rates remain elevated for some time.
The impact is close to even when comparing the relative performance against the broader S&P 500 with both periods resulting in a ~6% increase in the spread.
Utility firms are also likely to outperform in case of a US recession. Although some of the concerning economic data has normalized over the past week, the risk of a recession in the US persists. As utility firms provide essential services, their cash flows are relatively stable even during recessions. While consumers may cut down on discretionary spending, spending on essential services remains unaffected.
Mint Finance previously covered these factors in a separate paper.
HYPOTHETICAL TRADE SETUP
A pivot in Fed Policy is expected in the upcoming FOMC meetings with the CME FedWatch tool signaling 100 basis points of rate cuts in 2024 itself. Rate cuts will impact different sectors differently. While utility firms stand to benefit from lower rates, financial firms may see lower profits.
Source: CME FedWatch
The spread between CME E-Mini Utilities Select Sector Futures (XAU) and CME E-Mini Financial Select Sector Futures (XAF) has been rising since March as it has favored XAU. The spread responded strongly to a shift in rate cut sentiment as well as the recession signal at the start of the month.
The recent correction over the past week offers an improved entry point into the spread.
A hypothetical trade setup using XAU futures expiring in September (XAUU2024) and XAF futures expiring in September (XAFU2024) is described below. CME offers margin offset totaling 60% for this spread reducing the capital requirement to USD 3,740.
MARKET DATA
CME Real-time Market Data helps identify trading set-ups and express market views better. If you have futures in your trading portfolio, you can check out on CME Group data plans available that suit your trading needs tradingview.com/cme.
DISCLAIMER
This case study is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment recommendations or advice. Nor are they used to promote any specific products, or services.
Trading or investment ideas cited here are for illustration only, as an integral part of a case study to demonstrate the fundamental concepts in risk management or trading under the market scenarios being discussed. Please read the FULL DISCLAIMER the link to which is provided in our profile description.